
Neither a long-term nor a short-term rental is better for every owner. A long-term rental suits you if you value stability and a lower workload. A short-term rental suits you if you want flexibility and want to use the property yourself, but it needs more active management. This guide compares them, including what the property management looks like for each, so you can choose with a clear picture.
Key Takeaways
Long term means stability. A tenancy gives more consistent income, less turnover and less day-to-day work.
Short term means flexibility. You can keep the property for your own use, and rates can be higher in strong-demand periods, but the workload is heavier.
The costs move with the model. Arnona and building fees are often paid by the tenant on a long rental, so put it in the lease.
Compare net income. Judge each option on what remains after costs, empty months and tax.
Check the rules and take advice. ID Real Estate can recommend qualified accountants and lawyers.
Not sure which model fits your property? Tell Idith and the ID Real Estate team about your property and how you want to use it. Discover our property management services or contact us.
Important: General information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Check with licensed professionals. Rules and rates can change. Before you decide, take advice from a licensed Israeli lawyer and tax adviser who know your situation.
Fact check: the official sources listed below were read between 16 and 18 November 2026. Last updated 18 November 2026.
What is the difference between a long-term and a short-term rental?
A long-term rental is a tenancy under a rental agreement for a longer period. A short-term rental is a stay of a limited period, such as a few days or weeks. The table sets the two side by side.
Question | Long-term rental | Short-term rental |
|---|---|---|
Income | More consistent and predictable | Potentially higher rates in strong-demand periods |
Turnover | Less frequent | More frequent |
Own use of the property | Committed for the length of the tenancy | More flexibility for your own stays |
Day-to-day workload | Lower | Higher: guests, check-ins, cleaning |
Costs the tenant may carry | Arnona and building fees, depending on the lease | Depends on the arrangement |
Empty periods | Fewer, but a notice period between tenants | More frequent, and they need planning |
Rules to check | The lease terms | Tax, municipal, building and regulatory requirements |
When does a long-term rental suit you?
A long-term rental is generally better suited to owners looking for stability and predictable monthly income. You trade flexibility for it: the property is committed for the length of the tenancy.
On a long rental, tenants may cover costs such as arnona and the va’ad bayit, depending on the lease. The Ministry of Finance notes that in rental dwellings tenants rather than owners generally pay arnona (Ministry of Finance, 2023). The Ministry of Aliyah and Integration says that in most cases the tenant also pays the monthly dues of the building committee (Ministry of Aliyah and Integration, 2019). Our guide to the costs of renting out a property explains who usually pays what.
Long-term property management is the day-to-day care of a tenancy when the owner cannot be there. It includes tenant screening, the rental agreement, follow-up of payments, renewals, maintenance and communication. On a long-term rental, rent is paid directly into the owner’s own bank account, and ID Real Estate follows up on payments.
When does a short-term rental suit you?
A short-term rental can offer more flexibility, particularly if you still want to use the property yourself during parts of the year. Payments are usually collected before each stay. The trade-off is a heavier workload and the need to manage periods without occupancy.
Short-term property management covers guest communication, check-in and check-out, cleaning between stays, regular inspections, maintenance and repairs, and preparing the property for each new occupancy. For example, an owner who lives abroad and keeps the apartment for the summer will need someone local to prepare it before each arrival.
Check the applicable tax, municipal, building and regulatory requirements before you operate a property as a short-term rental. We are not aware of an official source that sets them out in one place, so ask your lawyer and your municipality about your own property.
Which option should you choose?
There is no single answer. Start from how you live with the property:
You live abroad and want little involvement. A long-term rental, with a local point of contact, may fit best.
You come for a few weeks each year. A short-term model can leave the property free for you, but plan who prepares it and who handles the guests.
You want predictable income. Compare a long tenancy with the empty months you can afford.
You may sell or move in later. Ask your lawyer what each lease allows.
Location, property type, expected expenses and tax should all be taken into account. Our guide to earning rental income from your property in Israel walks through the steps from the first decision to the lease.
What do costs and tax look like for each option?
Compare the two options on net income, not on rent alone: subtract the costs you pay, the months without a tenant or guest, and the tax your adviser confirms.
Rental income from a residential apartment can be taxable in Israel, and the route depends on your situation. The Israel Tax Authority describes three options for a residential apartment (Israel Tax Authority, 2026). Short-term or business-like rental activity may be treated differently from a standard residential tenancy. Ask a licensed Israeli tax adviser, ID Real Estate can recommend qualified accountants and lawyers.
Which questions should you ask before you decide?
How often do I want to use the property myself?
How many empty months can I afford?
Who will handle the tenants or the guests while I am away?
Which costs does the lease leave with me, and which with the tenant?
Which tax, municipal, building and regulatory requirements apply to my property?
What does my insurance cover for this kind of use?
Frequently asked questions
Is a long-term or a short-term rental more profitable?
There is no single answer. Short stays can bring higher rates in strong-demand periods, and long tenancies bring more consistent income. Compare the net income of each option after costs, empty months and tax.
Who pays arnona on a rented property?
The Ministry of Finance notes that in rental dwellings tenants rather than owners generally pay arnona (Ministry of Finance, 2023). Write who pays into the lease, and ask your lawyer how it applies to your property.
Does a property manager work with both models?
ID Real Estate can coordinate the rental and the ongoing management of your property, whether it is a long tenancy or a short-term arrangement. The workload is different for each, so tell us how you want to use the property.
Can I use my property myself and still rent it out?
Yes, depending on the rental arrangement. A short-term model leaves more room for your own stays, and a long tenancy commits the property for its length.
What are the next steps?
Decide how often you want to use the property, compare the two models on net income, and talk to a team that can coordinate the rental for you.
Ready to talk about your property? Contact Idith and the team, or read our guide to property management in Israel.
How did we check the facts?
Methodology: the statements about who pays arnona and building fees come from the two official government documents listed below, which we read on 18 November 2026. The tax options come from the Israel Tax Authority guide, which we re-read on 16 November 2026. The comparison of the two models, including the points on income and workload, is general information based on the services ID Real Estate offers. We did not find an official source that sets out the rules for short-term rentals.
About the author
Idith Dahan is a licensed real estate agent (licence no. 3156684) and founded ID Real Estate in 2015. She was born and raised in Israel, lived for more than 20 years in Europe, and now works with owners and buyers from her office in Herzliya (about the founder).
Disclaimer
General information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Check with licensed professionals. This article does not create a professional relationship. Rules, rates and local practice change, and ID Real Estate does not guarantee that the information is complete, correct or current. Before you make any decision or sign any document, take advice from a licensed Israeli lawyer and tax adviser who know your situation, and check the current rules with the Israel Tax Authority and your municipality. Each reader is responsible for verifying this information to avoid legal and financial problems.
Notes and sources
All sources are official Israeli government pages.
Israel Ministry of Finance, press release “The Ministry of Finance handed out the economic plan for the years 2023-2024 for public comments” (15 February 2023), footnote 1, read on 18 November 2026. It states that in rental dwellings tenants rather than owners generally pay arnona. gov.il page.
Ministry of Aliyah and Integration, “Housing in Israel” (2nd edition, autumn 2019), read on 18 November 2026. It says that in most cases the tenant pays the monthly dues of the residents’ committee (va’ad bayit). gov.il guide (PDF).
Israel Tax Authority, “Guide for Tax Payments and Relief on Rental Income of Residential Apartments in Israel” (updated 1 June 2026), read on 16 November 2026. It describes the three options for taxing rental income. gov.il guide.

MORE POSTS




